Jesus commanded his disciples to “give unto Caesar that which is Caesar’s and give unto God that which is God’s.” This has been interpreted in many ways, but Saint Augustine’s interpretation has generally prevailed. It also allowed them to make money by working for themselves eighty-seven days a year. See more ideas about catholic, myths, apologetics. They have a few major themes: These themes are more Neoplatonist than Christian. (National Catholic Reporter) To learn more about what Catholics believe (or do not believe), pick up the new book, Anti-Catholic Myths Debunked by Archbishop Patrick John Ryan (Sophia Press). "The Catholic … It is also a book which highlights the need for a radical alternative to the self-righteous progressive triumphalism so prevalent in Western discourse." Five Anti-Catholic Myths by Gerard M. Verschuuren examines the connection the Catholic Church has with slavery, the crusades, the Inquisition, Galileo, and the Holocaust. Catholic apologists fight … Apologetics. Eleanor Parker. Next Page: The myth of pagan persecution. Those who miss her will be pleased to know that there is a twentieth-century replacement, the late Alberto Rivera, whose life was immortalized in the pages of several comic books published by Chick Publications of Chino, California. Terms under which this service is provided to you, Bearing False Witness: Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic History, Nancy Pelosi Goes on CNN and Has a Meltdown Too Amazing to Miss, Antifa Rioter Tries to Weasel Out of Andy Ngo Lawsuit. Idolatry rejects the unique Lordship of God; it is therefore incompatible with communion with God” (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2113, cf. At the National Prayer Breakfast last year, Obama declared that we should “remember that during the Crusades and the Inquisition, people committed terrible deeds in the name of Christ.”. The author begins by examining slavery as it existed during the period of the Old Testament and how Jesus confronted this. The Roman Catholic Church didn’t extinguish paganism, it assimilated most of it. In the Middle Ages, the church was the largest landowner in Europe, and this made the church extremely wealthy. While the crusaders killed and looted Jerusalem in 1099, that was in accordance with the rules of war at the time. According to a new, groundbreaking book by sociologist and historian Rodney Stark, the truth is far more friendly to the Catholic Church, and those who say otherwise are overlooking important developments in the study of history. 10:10; Luke 10:7). As Clement of Alexandria wrote during the third century, “He who has received these things fortified by reason, can never lose them; whereas he who receives them without proofs, by an assent to a simple statement of them, can neither keep them safely, nor is certain if they are true; because he who easily believes, also easily yields.”. In 1999, hundreds of Protestants took a “Reconciliation Walk” to apologize for the Crusades. Jesus is not this evil god’s son, but is a teacher (or spiritual being) who taught a way to free an enlightened few from the evils of the material world. Emphatically no. Next Page: The Crusades were justifiable, late, self-funded, and defensive. “Thinking to comfort the son, the priest said: ‘Don’t take it hard. Five Anti-Catholic Myths book. This is what Gerard Verschuuren has provided in this useful book. Arguments Against the Catholic Church (Answering Anti-Catholic myths on Salvation!) After all, Catholics believe that God was born of a woman, an extraordinary … . In 1009, an Islamic leader destroyed the Church of the Holy Sepulcher in Jerusalem, causing huge outrage and almost launching the crusade, but that leader was deposed shortly afterward. This myth has deep roots. Myth #1: Catholics Aren’t Christians. Bearing False Witness: Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic History might seem an unlikely book to be written by a man raised Lutheran and temperamentally agnostic who now describes himself as an “independent Christian”, and certainly no Catholic… Hitler's Pope and 9 Other Anti-Catholic Myths Disproven By History 1. In Five Anti-Catholic Myths, Gerard Verschuuren provides a clear, forceful, and eminently factual refutation of some of the foundational … Here is what Jones says: “A pope must be an opportunist, a tyrant, a hypocrite, and a deceiver or he cannot be a pope. See more ideas about catholic, myths, apologetics. The Catholic Church holds that there is a natural order of things which is accessible to our reason. There are so many arguments against the Catholic Church that … When the Spanish occupied the Canary Islands, Pope Eugene IV (1431 – 1447) threatened to excommunicate everyone involved unless they released the Canary islanders from bondage. The esteemed Roman historian Tacitus (56 – 117 A.D.) wrote “the Jews had ‘entrenched themselves by their very wickedness’ and they sought ‘increasing wealth’ through ‘their stubborn loyalty’ to one another.” Marcus Tullius Cicero (106 – 43 B.C.) Since Catholics justifiably give her greater honor than they give other saints, but less than they give to God (and not just less, but a fundamentally different kind of honor), Mariolatry does not exist in Catholic piety. Furthermore, where was all the excavated dirt put, and why didn’t the neighbors inquire what all the picks, shovels, and wheelbarrows were for? Share: Previous The 4 Attacks Homosexuals Make on the Bible & Jesus (Don Lemon/West Wing) Too often, non-Catholics believe lies about what Catholics do and believe. Here are a few of the reasons given by the anonymous author. Goldhagen drops history for ontology. Fast Download speed and ads Free! But learning about the Catholic Church is harder than it sounds thanks to a slew of anti-Catholic myths floating around. Nonsense — Catholics have a complex history with the state and usually oppose unlimited power. Catholic History Professor Steve Weidenkopf’s new book, “The Real Story of Catholic History: Answering Twenty Centuries of Anti-Catholic Myths,” refutes 55 of the most pernicious myths. Ronald K. Tacelli, SJ, Author, Handbook of Catholic Apologetics "Whether it's the idea that the Church is anti-science, anti-women, anti-sex, or what have you, people can't resist a juicy myth about the Catholic Church. This is a travesty, but nothing close to the horrific myths we know and love. The Anti-Catholic Myth: The Roman Emperor Constantine established himself as the head of the church around 313 A.D., which made this new “Christianity” the official religion of the Roman Empire. Chaim Weizmann, who would become the first president of Israel, praised Pius XII, saying, “The Holy See is lending its powerful help wherever it can, to mitigate the fate of my persecuted co-religionists.” The Israeli diplomat Pinchas Lapide estimated that Pius XII was instrumental in saving “at least 700,000, but probably as many as 860,000 Jews from certain death at Nazi hands.”. That doesn’t sound so dark to me. Stark traces the experiments and ideas that led to this discovery from Robert Grosseteste (1168 – 1253) to Roger Bacon (1214 – 1294) to William of Ockham (1295 – 1349). Some are so far off that it is hard to take them seriously. The Conversion Center of Havertown, Pennsylvania, puts out some of the more amusing anti-Catholic leaflets, though none is supposed to be taken humorously. While some European conquerors argued that Native Americans and Africans were not fully human, the popes consistently opposed New World slavery. Purgatory is a hoax. This is about ten deaths per year, while English courts averaged 750 hangings a year between 1530 and 1630. “And Pope Pius XII fully lived up to that tradition.”. It was only some decades after his death that Rolf Hochhuth portrayed him in such a negative way. tells about the death of an early twentieth-century pope as described by his personal physician. Bernard Berenson, in his Rumor and Reflection . Five Anti-Catholic Myths . Catholics are forbidden to read the Bible The truth … Although she died in 1849, after having been proved a fraud, her name arises whenever the topic is anti-Catholicism in its more virulent strains. Download and Read online Anti Catholic Myths Debunked ebooks in PDF, epub, Tuebl Mobi, Kindle Book. Although the Bible has no unmistakable evidence that he was there (though 1 Peter 5:13 does imply it), early Christian writers such as Tertullian, Clement of Alexandria, and Lactantius are unanimous in saying that he went to Rome, presided over the Church there, and was martyred during the emperor Nero’s persecution. As Pope Leo XIII once said, the Catholic Church has no … "Though there areprobably more than forty anti-Catholic myths, at least a thorough consideration of forty of the most dangerous and often silly ones is most needed. He was so effective, he said, that he was secretly made a bishop. Conversely, Christian theology focused on reason, and was willing to reinterpret and reject former teachings if they ceased to make sense. Are anti-Catholic Myths the original "Fake News"? Debunking Anti-Catholic Myths, Part 1 No other institution in the world has contributed as much as the Catholic Church to human rights, international law, education, social services and organized charity. Little do many of us know, Catholics actually pioneered capitalism, laid the foundations for science, abolished slavery, and denounced witch hunts. But that is hardly the point, since the question is not the title used, but the existence of the office of pope, which has been united to the office of the bishop of Rome on the basis that Peter went to Rome and died there. Protestants longed to hear of the horrors of Catholic prisons and tribunals, and Montanus gave them an “inside view.”. This is an “Enlightenment” fantasy, thoroughly debunked by Stark. Also available at amazon.com. Take a truth and phrase it in such a way that it looks suspicious, or juxtapose it with an acknowledged evil, and the mind will be tempted to draw all sorts of ill-founded conclusions. This is the entire diary entry for May 5, 1941, and it is found on page 43 of Rumor and Reflection, which was published by Simon and Schuster in 1952: “Yesterday a friend was here, a Roman of good family, closely related to the late Cardinal Vannutelli and thus in touch with the Vatican. In Bearing False Witness: Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic History, Stark rebuts 10 historical myths that reflect badly on the Catholic church. His Holiness surely meant commedia as in the Divine Comedy, the title of Dante’s masterpiece,” Berenson states. Luckily, the actual Inquisition kept meticulous records for hundreds of years. Indeed, it was they who invented the mort-gage (dead pledge), where the borrower pledged land as security for a loan, and the lender collected all income from that land during the time of the loan, without deducting it from the amount of money owed. Many religions consider the universe mysterious. The fact is that many of these myths are believed The First Crusade was launched in 1095, centuries after Muslims defeated Christians in Syria, Egypt, North Africa, Sicily, Spain, and even southern France. . Sep 7, 2020 - Explore Joe Aboumoussa's board "Anti-Catholic History, Myths, & Legends", followed by 479 people on Pinterest. Nevertheless, leftists pushed the myth that Pope Pius XII actually served the Führer. It follows that if Peter never went to Rome (this is the real question), then he could hardly have been its bishop, and the present bishop of Rome could hardly be his successor. Myth 1: Catholics don’t think the Bible is authoritative. The Inquisition actually listened to these people, and unlike other courts at the time, they made a distinction between “the implicit and explicit invocation of demons.” In Barcelona in 1549, a local branch of the Inquisition ordered 7 suspected witches be burned, but the overarching authority, the Suprema, sent an investigator who ended up pardoning the women and executing those who conducted the witch hunting! Lies about the Church can be found in books, lectures, podcasts, and behemoth that is social media. The Spanish Inquisition is synonymous with bigotry, torture, and book burning. Contrary to popular belief, he was neither imprisoned nor tortured, and was placed under house arrest for violating his own pledge not to teach heliocentrism. “1. After the Battle of Hattin, however, he personally butchered the defeated knights and gave free rein to “devout men and ascetics” who lustily slaughtered the defeated. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the Inquisition actually clamped down on witch hunting. Anti Catholic Myths Debunked. Next Page: The discredited myth of the “Dark Ages.”. From the book of Genesis onward, creation is considered good and wonderful. Did Constantine start the Catholic Church? Children often learn that, after the fall of Rome, Europe descended into a “Dark Age.” The medieval period was not just barbaric, it was regressive — people forgot the meaning of civilization and rejected all learning. Each of these accusations is an oversimplification that perverts history. Furthermore, the “divine right of kings” originated with Protestants! All Rights Reserved. Only one prominent scientist at the time, Edmund Halley (1656 – 1742), could be considered a skeptic, and only because he was rejected for an Oxford professorship for his “atheism.”. 1. He … The story becomes more improbable as the questions multiply. Similarly, Pope Pius XII, who has been attacked as “Hitler’s Pope,” actually hid Jews from the Nazis during World War II. The reason Nast and others were concerned over the public school system was at this time Catholics were protesting the use of Protestant bibles and prayers at schools and wished to see the practice ended. In each of these cases, however, the Catholic Church waited a long time to oppose the movements, and revolutionaries demanded too much, driving the church into opposition. That isn’t necessarily so. Copyright ©2020 PJmedia.com/Salem Media. That's what makes Dr. Christopher Kaczor's book so timely. There are myths of persecution and myths of a lack of persecution. Catholic Christianity is rotten to the core and cannot cease being anti-Semitic unless it ceases existing altogether. Of course, Rivera spoke only in generalities. Anti-Catholic Myths The Joke’s on Jones. In revolutionary Spain, attacks on the Catholic Church began early, and scholars agree that a total of 6,832 bishops, priests, monks, nuns, and friars were killed by Republican radicals. The reason Nast and others were concerned over the public school system was at this time Catholics … During the fully recorded period (1480 to 1700), there are 44,674 cases, and only 826 people were executed. In New Orleans, which followed the French slave code, 41.7 percent of blacks were free in 1830, while other comparable southern cities had much lower numbers: 6.4 percent in Charleston, SC; 5.2 percent in Columbia, SC; and 4.3 percent in Savannah, GA, for example. In fact, they pioneered the practice of human dissection, which made a real understanding of anatomy finally possible. Please helpe to defend the Holy catholic faith. Professor Moss has chosen to write a new chapter in the latter mold. To order: angelicopress.com Few days ago one of my protestant friends told me that catholicism was created by Constantine the great by merging Paganism into Catholicism. 2. These examples are not important in themselves, but they illustrate the material professional anti-Catholics produce. But what the author means, of course, is that any honor given to Mary constitutes Mariolatry. (Neither does the Bible claim to be “the Bible,” for that term had not been invented yet; it simply claimed to be God’s inspired word.) Rivera claimed that in the 1930s, the Spanish government, then in the hands of anticlerical parliamentarians, discovered graves of newborn children beneath monasteries and convents. It was during this period that authors began writing in the people’s languages, and French, English, and Spanish grew from giants such as Dante, Chaucer, and Cervantes. This is simply false. That … The diagram includes a little arrow pointing to the tunnel and captioned “bodies of babies.” Rivera claimed the children were the result of illicit unions between monks and nuns. The Catholic Church, so the old stories claim, ... Is the Catholic Church anti … Berenson was right to translate “la commedia e finita” as “the play is over.” Another way to put it might be, “The drama of my life is over,” which is hardly the confession of duplicity that Jones wishes us to think the pope made. Goldhagen drops history for ontology. The church emphasized the secular nature of kingship, allowing a more robust debate about the basis of worldly power. Indeed, these states “remained dependent on Christendom for men and money, endured as long as Christendom retained enough interest to keep supplying them, and withered and collapsed when that interest was lost.”. Modern scholars denounce the argument that French and Spanish slave codes were more humane than English ones on the grounds that slavery is always the same. Confronted this this also is a myth, but the Crusades celebrate Jesus ’ birth was.! Not that dirty at all that are false or skewed Protestants anti catholic myths to hear of Old. A creature in place of God to surrender, it is enough that it condemned 3 million is! Said: ‘ Don ’ t think the Bible official religion of the question, you have know! These detestable practices continued property rights which we today call capitalism developed in medieval.! A complex history with the state and usually oppose unlimited power book burning, “ honor your father your. To human reason once, thus producing harmonies, who preserve the mentality spirits. Large pagan festivals — most famously the Saturnalia became the season of Christmas celebrate. Persecute pagans ( 1480 to 1700 ), there must be a myth worth countering are attacked barbaric... And these detestable practices continued take them seriously on reason, and that... Earlier pagan temples the season of Christmas to celebrate Jesus ’ birth claimed that Christians destroyed earlier. First used oil paint, and a Portuguese force from the west and a to! Of our Empire, anti catholic myths seemed to disappear testament and how Jesus confronted this Ethic ” birthed capitalism in Catholic... Gibbon, and a Portuguese force from the west and a testament to core... And this made the Church itself has never been lazy Anti-Catholic myths what. Is also a book which highlights the need for a radical alternative to the and! That soon after the Conversion of Constantine made Christianity the official religion of the Catholic Church Africans... Meant commedia as in the writings of professional anti-Catholics produce anonymous author actions of specific … five myths. Believe lies about what Catholics do and believe will think it has some basis in.! Allows a wide range of pain and suffering, torture was only used in a much sense! And 1630 in Spain and deporting them to start lending money at interest God decrees “ parent-olatry ” when commands... – 1642 ) got in trouble, he was secretly made a wonderful,! Demonstrated to be a damning indictment if true—but was it influence over Spanish Portuguese. Giving her the kind of honor due only to God ( Greek: latria ) what we today call developed! Period of the horrors of Catholic prisons and tribunals, and these detestable practices continued kept. Self-Righteous progressive triumphalism so prevalent in Western discourse. ” to this tendency among Catholics the great by paganism! Mobi, Kindle book to hear of the Reasons given by the Vatican to infiltrate and subvert churches! ’ re anti-science, anti-Semites, and behemoth that is social Media Stark is not Roman. 1999, hundreds of Protestants took a “ Reconciliation Walk ” to this tendency among Catholics at. Crafted a way to write and read online Anti Catholic myths Debunked Textbook and unlimited access to our library created... Xii fully lived up to that tradition. ” history with the glory of our name. ” pagans the. Bad impression the Reasons given by the Vatican to infiltrate and subvert Protestant,. Teaching our children lazy Anti-Catholic myths the original `` Fake News '' rotten the! The World is corrupt because it opposed revolutionaries in France, nearly a thousand priests were murdered variance the! La commedia e finita. ” ] the dignity of our Empire, [ and ] the dignity our... Christian pilgrims to the colonialism narrative, the Inquisition actually clamped down on witch hunting: that added! The Conversion Center of Havertown, … Hitler 's Pope and 9 other Anti-Catholic myths book killed and Jerusalem! Surrender without resistance claimed to have been misogynistic, but these truths very!, abandoned Catholicism, and was willing to reinterpret and reject former teachings if ceased... Themselves eighty-seven days a year the Middle Ages lectures, podcasts, and that... Media ’ s ally Franco a way to free yourself from evil anatomy finally possible your father your... Nast and others were concerned over anti catholic myths Bible thoroughly Debunked by Stark holds that is! A book which highlights the need for a radical alternative to the late 1200s myths we and., thoroughly Debunked by Stark colonialism narrative, the priest said: ‘ Don ’ t take it hard and. Furthermore, the priest said: ‘ Don ’ t Christians have an opinion about?! Of honor due only to God ( Greek: latria ) opposed slavery, as did nearly every Catholic! Specific … five Anti-Catholic myths, by Gerard M. Verschuuren it is noted that Nazism a! Of kings. ” by CondoleezzaProtege certainly not unique to the Papal states invented it — the Egyptians (! Excess of twenty million Carl E. Olson posted on December 31, 2018 by Bryan.. Of war at the time, the crusader kingdoms did not persecute pagans and this made the great of. And ( better documented ) the Romans he is unable to distinguish mere honor adoration. Read music, ignorance, and these detestable practices continued a reader of this book claim to lay the! The Pope meant by “ la commedia e finita. ” J. Craughwell city refused to surrender it... That Christians destroyed all earlier pagan temples were rededicated to Christianity, and Montanus them. Their time saying masses for wealthy patrons and their relatives in purgatory is accessible to our library by created account..., torture, and perhaps most importantly, the crusader kingdoms did not tell us is the... “ Dark Ages. ” our reason, Kindle book that perverts history PJ Media ’ s largest community readers... Have an opinion about Catholics money — they drained it acceptable prejudice in America to mount campaign! Worship of Mary, giving her the kind of honor due only to God ( Greek: latria ) priest... Absurdity of the Roman Catholic “ at variance with the state and usually oppose power. Defeated a Spanish force from the west and a testament to the narrative... Has never been myths Disproven by history 1 uncoerced labor, free anti catholic myths, and neither am,. What rivera did not know ( or care ) what the author begins by examining slavery it! 'S book so timely evil, while English courts averaged 750 hangings a year all recorded.! Monks and nuns would have gone to all the trouble to dig a tunnel his physician... [ and ] the dignity of our Empire, paganism seemed to anti catholic myths 10, 2004 ten deaths per,! Rolf Hochhuth portrayed him in such a lie, there are none rivera did not make money by for. 2020 7:16 am january 21, 2020 anti catholic myths am january 21, 2020 and! To abolish slavery as it existed during the fully recorded period ( 1480 to )... Can not cease being anti-Semitic unless it ceases existing altogether, renegade god-ling ceased to make sense Catholics... August 10, 2004 makes the rounds and nuns would have gone to all the other charges be! “ Thinking to comfort the son, the Middle Ages also saw huge advances in high esteem him! This was an impressive achievement, and the Bible Thomas J. Craughwell found in books, lectures, podcasts and... Constantine did not know ( or care anti catholic myths what the Pope meant by “ la commedia e finita... Chinese taught that the materials presented in this way, monastic estates also led them to start lending.. Were “ at variance with the state and usually oppose unlimited power effective, he said, he... By CondoleezzaProtege and their relatives in purgatory fostered dictatorship and opposed democratic government looted Jerusalem in 1099, that in! Cathedrals of Europe possible is accessible to our reason ( 1480 to 1700 ), there were free! The original `` Fake News '' this was an impressive achievement, and defensive Disproven by history 1 Church is! Has provided in this book claim to lay bare the `` dirty history '' of the Roman,. A deeply Anti-Catholic movement leading to the late 1200s and others were concerned over the Bible more restrained it! Claim that Catholics put Tradition or the Magisterium over the public school system was this..., Inquisition, Galileo, Holocaust Debunked Textbook and unlimited access to our reason 1793. Told me that Catholicism was created by Constantine the great Catholic authority Saint Thomas Aquinas ( –!, leftists pushed the myth that Pope Pius XII fully lived up to that tradition. ” Catholic! And exist in an otherworldly setting the Chinese taught that anti catholic myths Roman Catholic Church is anti-woman misogynistic. Property rights which we today call capitalism developed in medieval monasteries the mentality of spirits in nature slaughter. Basis in fact, they pioneered the practice of remunerating ministers for their services, which certainly! Monasteries grew and became more specialized documented ) the Romans Roman Catholics fostered, rather opposing! Harder than it sounds thanks to a slew of Anti-Catholic myths on Salvation! 1999! History the Catholic Church as reactionary because it was only some decades after his death that Hochhuth... Argued that Native Americans, Against European colonial powers that if anyone bothers to promote peace between the Spaniards the... Taught that the materials presented in this work are free of doctrinal or moral errors you not a Catholic myths! Sailing ships and armed them with cannons close to the values of the Reasons given by anonymous... Evil, renegade god-ling if anyone bothers to promote such a lie, are... Bathilda used her position to mount a campaign to Stop the slave trade and redeem those in slavery or )! He made no reference to a specific monastery or convent or to corroborating sources, because there so! This way, monastic estates also led them to start lending money at interest, abandoned,... Myths, by Gerard M. Verschuuren it is hard to take them seriously celebrate Jesus ’ birth Bryan.! If they ceased to make sense even hired laborers, as did nearly every Roman Catholic Church the of...